The late builder Robert McElroy’s custom Malvern residence, filled with handcrafted woodwork and surrounded by lush scenery, is now on the market for $1.99 million.
Body Paragraph:
Tucked deep within Willistown Township, this 4,300-square-foot property known as the McElroy House has officially hit the market. Designed and built in 1975 by Main Line builder Robert McElroy for his family, the home showcases his passion for craftsmanship and design. With floor-to-ceiling windows, a spiral staircase, and a private five-acre setting, the residence feels like a live-in work of art.
Key Points:
-
Listed for $1.99 million, the McElroy House spans 4,300 square feet on five wooded acres in Willistown Township.
-
The home was crafted by Robert McElroy, who built more than 200 Main Line properties, for himself and his artist wife Annamaria.
-
Nearly every wooden element was custom-made by artisan Horace Hartshaw, a collaborator of sculptural furniture icon Wharton Esherick.
-
A detached two-story garage and an art studio wing offer creative and functional potential for future owners.
Preserved with remarkable care, the McElroy House stands as a testament to timeless design and artistry. Its next chapter awaits a buyer who values creativity, nature, and handcrafted beauty.
By: Erin McCarthy | The Philadelphia Inquirer | October 20, 2025
Photo: Courtesy of Thomas Donkin
